Strategic Talent Acquisition for a Startup P&C Carrier

December 20, 2024

Discover how Lyneer Search Group delivered a Group Controller for a fast-growing insurance startup in under 43 days, overcoming market constraints with precision and strategy.

Client Overview


Industry:  Property & Casualty Insurance


Profile: A startup carrier with an innovative distribution model seeking to establish scalable financial processes and build a dynamic team culture.


Search Overview


Position: Group Controller


Objective: Secure a leader to spearhead financial reporting, process development, and team-building initiatives tailored to a startup environment.


Challenges


 Startup Dynamics


The client needed a candidate skilled in building scalable systems and fostering a collaborative, high-performing culture.


Limited Talent Pool


The client’s smaller geographic market made it challenging to identify professionals with insurance accounting expertise and startup experience.


Lyneer’s Approach: Tailored Talent Solutions


Nationwide Search:


Conducted a comprehensive search across the U.S. to identify candidates with the technical expertise and cultural adaptability required.


Targeted Local Market Mapping:


Focused on uncovering talent in the client’s local area to streamline onboarding and reduce relocation challenges.


Proactive Candidate Engagement:


Reached out to 46% of the targeted candidate pool, prioritizing professionals with experience in Property & Casualty insurance accounting and startup leadership.


Presenting Top Candidates:


 Delivered a shortlist of six highly qualified candidates, including three local professionals, to provide the client with a diverse and tailored selection.


Outcome: A Strategic Match in Record Time


Lyneer Search Group successfully placed a local candidate within 43 days of commencing the search.


Immediate Impact: The candidate brought sophisticated financial reporting capabilities, built scalable processes, and fostered a collaborative organizational culture.


Client Success: The hire exceeded expectations, addressing critical leadership needs and positioning the startup for sustained growth.


Client Feedback: “Lyneer’s approach to understanding our unique needs and tailoring the search to our market challenges was exceptional. The candidate has been instrumental in shaping our financial operations and team culture.”


Proven Success in Talent Acquisition


46% Engagement Rate: Connected with nearly half of the targeted candidate pool.


43 Days to Placement: Rapid turnaround to meet the client’s urgent leadership requirements.


90% Quality of Hire:  9/10 candidates placed by Lyneer are promoted at least once, highlighting the long-term impact of our talent solutions.


Ready to Find Your Next Leader?


Whether you’re a startup or an established enterprise, Lyneer Search Group is here to help you secure top-tier talent for critical roles.


Learn More About Our Services Explore Career Opportunities


Explore More Success Stories


Discover how Lyneer delivers tailored solutions for unique hiring challenges:


View All Case Studies
AI Study
September 9, 2025
A new Stanford study shows AI is cutting entry-level finance jobs while senior roles grow. What hiring managers need to know in 2025.
Insurance
August 20, 2025
The insurance workforce faces a critical talent shortage. Learn how transferable skills in insurance hiring, Gen Z strategies, and Lyneer’s AI insurance recruitment tools fill roles fast. Lyneer Search Group, an insurance recruiting agency is based in Holmdel, NJ.
Finance, Insurance, Hiring
August 5, 2025
Discover how the July 2025 jobs report impacts hiring in finance and insurance. Learn what roles are in demand, salary trends, and how HR teams can stay agile in a shifting market.
Accounting & Finance Recruiting Trends
July 17, 2025
Explore 2025 hiring insights, salary trends, and emerging skill demands shaping finance talent in insurance, financial services, and wealth management. Including BLS 2025 data, finance & insurance job openings up 91k, wages +3.5% YoY, remote work 33%.
Bridging generational gaps in accounting and finance.
July 3, 2025
Learn how finance and accounting recruiters in insurance and wealth management can build inclusive, multi-generational teams that drive performance and client trust.
Top 250 Executive Search Firm
June 27, 2025
Lyneer Search Group has been named to HuntScanlon Media’s 2025 list of America’s Top 250 Executive Search Firms. Discover what sets us apart.
Wealth Management Salary Guide
By Karen Childers June 12, 2025
MFO Multifamily Office Salary Trends for the United States based on the Lyneer Search Group MFO Salary Guide for 2025.
Insurance Industry Salary Trends
By Karen Childers June 11, 2025
Insurance Industry Salary Trends for 2025
Executive Recruitment
May 6, 2025
Two of our most experienced recruiters were brought in to fill a critical executive role. Shortly after a sudden leadership exit, added to the complexity. The landscape was anything but simple: internal miscommunications, hesitant candidates, and a narrow salary band made the situation fragile. The entire process could have easily unraveled
Insurance Accounting and Finance Partnership
April 25, 2025
Discover how Lyneer Search Group connects insurance firms with elite finance talent through strategic executive search and deep industry relationships.